Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
1925-1935
  • From American Reading Instruction by Nila Banton Smith, pages 185-246
2
Period of Intense Research
  • New emphasis in public schools that embraced silent reading, speed, reading disability, and other innovactions
3
Two Divergent Opinions
  • One group of theorists believed that children should be given practice on sequenced skills that are carefully planned by an adult
  • The other group was convinced that learning best took place when the child was allowed to carry out his/her own purposes, meeting and solving problems within the context of experience and through own activities
4
Research of the Era Looked At
  • How adults used reading in their lives
  • Children’s reading interests
5
Approaches to Reading
  • Varied approaches to teaching reading and included
    • Reading charts composed by children
    • Reading Mother Goose rhymes, plus stories composed by the children
    • Reading and performing action sentences plus reading stories composed by children about pictures
    • Dramatizing the pictures and phrases and sentences concerning them
    • Telling the first book story, then dramatizing and reproducing it
    • Reading from prepared charts containing the early primer vocabulary
6
Phonics
  • Some teachers believed phonics instruction to be misplaced and that it had no value.
  • No textbook series abandoned phonics completely
7
Key Figures
  • Gates—Work Play Books
    • Gates against phonics drills in isolation and in favor of practice exercises in which children had to discriminate among word forms in meaningful settings.  Favored systematic, sequential instruction

8
"Pennel and Cusak—phonics,"
  • Pennel and Cusak—phonics, when wisely taught, is justified for most children because it provides independence in the recognition of words