Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
1880’s to 1910
  • From American Reading Instruction by Nila Banton Smith, pages 108-147
2
Cultural Influences Changed Reading Instruction
  • Schools should not only teach reading, but cultivate in the child a taste for good literature



3
Herbarts
  • Herbartian principles popular in Germany
  • One goal was to develop character through the use of literary and historical stories
  • In Flint, Michigan—”The purpose of the courses in reading is threefold: first, to teach children to read; second, to cause children to like to read; third, to enable them to know and prefer good literature.”
4
Professional Books in Reading
  • First came on the scene
  • 1888: Scudders Literature in the Schools
  • Edmund Blake Huey: The Psychology and Pedagogy of Reading
    • First “scientific” contribution to reading instruction and focused on “the hygiene of reading, the history of reading, and the psychology of reading
  • 1889: Reading: How to Teach It  by Sarah Louise Arnold
    • Emphasis is on the development of an appreciation for good literature


5
"George Mirick of the New..."
  • George Mirick of the New Jersey Department of Public Instruction published The Teaching of Reading in 1914.
    • Included discussions on phonetics, voice training, and the use of the blackboard
    • Advocated for lots of silent reading
6
Supplemental Materials
  • First time reading materials other than those included in basic reader became popular practice
  • Reading in upper grades to the form of classical literature
  • Fairy tales popular for younger grades (like “The Three Bears”)
7
Scientific Alphabet Approach
  • Reduced number of characters needed in representing sounds by respelling words and omitting silent letters.
  • Shearer System did something similar
    • Wuns, Ri Van Win-kl went up
      • A-mung the hilz, hwar hi sa
      • Cwir lit-l men ple-ing bel
8
"“A"
  • “A child may be taught the art of reading, not fluently, but well both in phonetic and in ordinary books, in three months—aye, often in twenty hours of thorough instruction, a task which is rarely accomplished in three years of toll by the old alphabet.”
9
General Features of New Methods
  • Used sentences and story
  • More elaborate phonetic methods that stressed teaching letters and combinations of letters
    • Stories with animals or other creatures making sounds and children would draw letters on blackboard and make sounds (P and make a puff sound when drawing the curve of the letter)(part of the idea was to make the work interesting for children)
  • Appreciation of literature, usually for older children, and involved defining and dissecting literature and began to move away from the elocutionary approach
10
Basal Readers Changed
  • Elocution lessons began to disappear
  • Moralist and information selections diminished
  • Mother Goose and folktales used for the first time
  • Cloth covers replaced cardboard covers


11
Beginnings of Reading Research
  • Mainly psychological and physiological in nature
  • Called attention to rate in reading, distinctions between silent and oral reading, and individual differences in reading.
  • Key figures included
    • I.O. Quantz
    • Walter F. Dearborn
    • Edmond B. Huey
    • R.S. Woodworth
    • E.B. Holt